Let’s start out the analytics process with a look at the big picture. The Orioles as of July 31, 2013 are 59-49 and in the thick of the playoff hunt. They still have a fair chance at catching the Rays and/or Red Sox and if that plan fails, they are in good shape to contend for one of the wild card spots all the way down to the wire. After many years of uncompetitive baseball in Baltimore, the Orioles organization isn’t about to let last year’s long overdue taste of success pass flash in the pan. They have their focus set on winning now and getting back to the postseason. With that in mind, its understandable the Dan Duquette has been one of the more aggressive GM’s this month of July. After picking up Scott Feldman and Francisco Rodriguez previously, he pulled the trigger on a deal for Bud Norris too in an effort to augment a rotation that has struggled to get consistent quality starts beyond Wei-Yin Chen, Chris Tillman, and for the most part, Miguel Gonzalez.
Getting to Know Bud Norris
- Full Name: David Stefan Norris (Bud = Nickname)
- Born: March 2, 1985 in Greenbrae, CA
- Age: 28
- Height: 6′ 0”
- Weight: 220
- Bats: Right
- Throws: Right
- College: Cal Poly San Luis Obispo
- Drafted: 6th Round, 2006
- MLB Debut: July 29, 2009
- Signed Through: 2015
Scouting Report (Based on my stat and video analysis)
Fastball: 55 – 91-94 MPH; Not much movement; Effective when spotted down in the zone; average command of pitch
Slider: 65 – 84-86 MPH; Good late break; Swing-and-miss offering; mediocre command of pitch; gets away with mediocre command due to plus break on pitch
Changeup: 40 – 84 – 86 MPH; Little depth or fade; Below average pitch; lacks ideal velocity separation from fastball
Command: 55 – Solid-Average overall; At his best he locates his fastball on the low corners well and sets up his above average slider for the strikeout pitch; Has little feel for changeup and occasionally has lapses in fastball command causing the pitch to flatten out up in the zone.
Control: 50 – Average control; Above average strike throwing ability against right handed batters whom his above average fastball-slider combo plays more effectively against. Average to Below Average with lefties who have an easier time laying off the slider, resulting in fewer swinging strikes, and a tendency to try to nibble with them due to a below average changeup that will get hit hard if he leaves it over the plate.
Sidenote: Not sure if Norris has tinkered around with a cutter or not but I think a hard upper 80’s cutter could help neutralize his sharp platoon split. I noticed that back in 2010 when he threw his slider more in the 86-88 MPH range, he had more success getting left handed batters out. Easier said than done as he would have to be able to command the cutter with good bite in a consistent velocity range and that is difficult to hone overnight.
What The Orioles Gave Up
Josh Hader, LHP – Sad to see the local boy done good story leave town. The reality is though that he is still far away from the majors and with a crossfire delivery and current control inconsistencies, may profile better as a lefty reliever anyway. If that’s what he becomes, we may feel bad that he didn’t make it up with his hometown team, but this is a business, that’s who the Astros wanted, and a potential lefty reliever isn’t something to lose sleep over. Now, if Hader continues to grow into his lanky frame, improves his durability as a starter, sharpens his command and quality of his secondary pitches, and reaches his mid-rotation upside, we probably will regret including him the deal. Ultimately, he wouldn’t have been a factor in the Orioles plans, who are in “win-now” mode, until at least 2016, so it’s a gamble Dan Duquette is willing to make.
L.J. Hoes – LF – I just did a big “Welcome To The Show” profile on Mr. Hoes the other day, and now he’s gone. I speculated in my profile that part of the reasoning behind bringing Hoes up could have been marketing him in front of major league scouts for a potential deadline trade. Right I was, as the Orioles shipped (and by shipped I mean made him walk across the field) Hoes off to the visiting Astros where he will become an immediate starter in the outfield. Hoes deserves this opportunity and I’m actually somewhat glad to see him go. He has nothing left to prove in the minors and wasn’t a factor in a crowded Orioles outfield picture. He’ll get regular time in Houston and if he ever develops a little more in game pop, he’ll become a solid everyday starter and an ideal two hole hitter with his ability to post high walk totals and make consistent contact.
Competitive Balance Pick – I’m going to miss having this pick which is #32 overall, especially if the rumors that next year’s draft will be loaded are true. That being said, the draft is a crapshoot and this pick is a luxury the Orioles can afford to give the Astros.
Overall Thoughts
I get the reasoning behind the trade. The Orioles want to bolster the rotation for the stretch run without having to surrender premium prospects which they accomplished. But, is Bud Norris a guy they can count on to get the job done against the better lineups the Orioles will need to beat down the stretch and possibly in the playoffs. I’m not so sure. He strikes me as another Scott Feldman type. Both profile as solid No.4/ No.5 starters in a first division rotation; the kind of pitchers that are mostly dependable to give the team at least 6 innings each time out, will hold the weaker team’s lineups to 3 ER or less, but can be overmatched against the better team’s lineups and will get tagged for 4-6 runs IF they don’t bring their A game. Basically, what I’m getting at is I’m skeptical about whether Norris will much of a difference maker for the Orioles, especially against their AL East rivals.
Here’s Why:
On the season, left handed batters have hit Norris to the tune of .300/.365/.494 with 10 Home Runs allowed in 277 at bats. Basically, lefty batters have combined to hit like Manny Machado against Norris. Right handed batters have combined to hit .240/.305/.315 against him in 220 at bats. It’s no secret, the below average changeup is the main factor behind this split.
Norris also has a pronounced home/road split, pitching to a 2.92 ERA at Minute Maid Park in Houston and a 5.91 ERA everywhere else.
The pronounced home/road split also applies to his ability to get lefty batters out. Against 95 total lefty batters faced on the road, Norris has been hit to the tune of .356/.411/.659. That’s Miguel Cabrera esque.
I’m worried about how those below average numbers will translate to a ballpark like Camden Yards with a short right field porch tailor made for left handed power hitters.
I could be overblowing all of this statistical nonsense and he may end up working around his splits in his new home setting. After all, he absolutely seemed more comfortable pitching at the Astros home field. Perhaps, Bud Norris has a thing for pitching in front of the home crowd, regardless of the team he plays for. We’ll see. There’s really no way of telling how the home/road splits translate from one team to the next.
On a more positive note, another factor that can’t be overlooked is the stellar Orioles defense that will now play behind Norris. The Astros were on the lower end of the spectrum defensively so moving up to the Orioles defense could certainly help him overcome, or at least better hide his weaknesses. A stronger defense could help mitigate big scoring innings from happening by preventing fewer runners on base if/when Norris does struggle with the extra base hits allowed to left handed batters.
Ultimately, I’m expecting Norris to pitch around a 4.00 ERA and give the Orioles a winning chance in most of his outings. However, I’m still not sold this is a guy that can be counted on against the better hitting lineups versus right handed pitching like the Red Sox (1), Tigers (3), and Athletics (4), all teams the Orioles may need to count on him against in a big game down the stretch or possibly the playoffs.
Was this a fair trade?
Yes, in terms of value subtracted versus value added, I think Orioles did well giving up two B-level prospects and a Comp B pick for a decent No.4 starter who is under team control through 2015. However, getting back to the original points I made in the introduction to this post about the Orioles focus on getting to the postseason, I’m not sure Norris is someone the Orioles needed to pursue. He has a reliever’s two pitch arsenal and may not be able to hold his own as a starter at Camden Yards the same way he did in Houston. I’m okay with this trade but not in love with it. In a perfect world, I think the Orioles would have been better served to combine the players/prospects involved in the Feldman, K-Rod, and Norris trades into one mega package for a Matt Garza or Jake Peavy. I’ll never know if that was ever a realistic scenario, but a frontline starter is what this team needs to get past their contending rivals in the American League.